6mm · AAR · Ancients · Greeks · Peloponnesian War · Sword & Spear

Just played: Sword & Spear

sacredbandofthebes

A little while back, me and Jonas met up at club for a test game of Sword & Spear, using my 6mm Greeks. Last time I played it it became apparent that the system isn’t really designed with too complex scenarios in mind, so this time we went for a more traditional approach: a straight up pitched battle.

Sword & Spear features a rather elaborate points system, which mainly I disregarded last time. But now I wanted to try how it worked, so I wrote two lists (points values are based on the Polkovnik army lists):

Spartans:

1 General @50p

1 Captain @30p

3 units of Spartan Hoplites @44p

1 large unit of Spartan Hoplites @54p

1 unit of Psiloi @9p

275 points in total

Athenians:

1 General @50p

1 Captain @30p

1 large unit of Elite Hoplites @54p

8 units of Poor Quality Hoplites @20p

3 units of Peltasts @9p

1 unit of Citizen Cavalry @18p

1 unit of Thessalian Cavalry @15p

276 points in total

*

We also reduced the number of terrain pieces on the table. Rather than getting caught up in complex maneuvers – something that my last game suffered a bit from – we wanted to test how the combat system worked in fights between two equally strong forces.

This meant that the table looked a bit naked and empty, but since this was a test game we didn’t mind (too much).

20160102_141050So here the two armies advance against each other (Spartans on the left, Athenians on the right). Skirmishers from both sides rush out towards the flank while the heavy infantry march straight ahead. For the sake of speed and playability, we used inches instead of centimeters – in 6mm, movement tend to be rather slow otherwise.

20160102_142534Because of their speed and ease of movement, the skirmishers make contact first. Some javelins are exchanged and a unit of Athenian Peltasts immediately bites the dust.

I was actually a bit surprised that Peltasts basically have the same stats and point value as Psiloi; while both are correctly classed as skirmishers, the Peltasts were often professional warriors and carried shields, while Psiloi generally had far less training and equipment (in Sparta’s case they were almost exclusively Helots, i.e. slaves). In future games I’ll probably do some houseruling to reflect this.

20160102_142529The Athenians form up into two huge blocks and start moving as a group – S&S has a rather neat system for this were action dice are used for all troops but only one die needs to be actively rolled and allocated.

20160102_14105420160102_143841Meanwhile the Spartans’ main force take up position next to the wheat field, while a Hoplite unit turns toward the right flank…

20160102_145422…but the Athenian Citizen Cavalry it is trying to engage makes a sharp turn, avoiding both the infantry and Psiloi and positioning themselves so as to make proper use of the road (a unit with its center on a road gains a bonus move).

And now the ultra light and super fast Thessalian Cavalry has sneaked round the back, through the village, and rapidly approaches from the left flank.

20160102_145049The scene is obviously set for a confrontation that is bound to get ugly. Both sides brace themselves for the impact…

…and then slam into each other with brutal force. The large unit of Spartans inevitably gets the upper hand, given their superior discipline and effectiveness (plus some handy sixes).

20160102_153821But the Athenians are more numerous – this is clearly a case of quality versus quantity.

20160102_15334420160102_160650Also, the Spartans are in trouble on the right flank, as a lone unit of Hoplites is caught in the open and flanked by Athenian Cavalry.

From here things go downhill pretty fast for the Spartans. They lose their only protection on their left, which opens up for an Athenian flank charge. And to make matters even worse the Thessalians now have the indecency to ram right into the unprotected Spartan rear. The boys in red are jammed between a rock and a hard place, and in the end even they are unable to withstand such a treatment.

When this large, costly unit breaks the Army Value is down to less than a third to its original number and all the other units are forced to make discipline tests. And that spells the end for the Spartans. Like so often throughout history, Quantity rubs Quality’s face in the dirt.

*

Overall we had fun, even though the whole “two equally strong lines of infantry clashing in a field” shenanigans is perhaps not the most exciting thing in the world. However, we did get a good feel for the system and its strengths and limitations.

I’d like to play some more games before I give a final verdict on Sword & Spear though – next time I’ll probably want to try out the rules for baggage camps, stratagems and multi-player games.

And of course, everything will be documented and posted here on Hook Island, so stay tuned for more ancients action!

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Just played: Sword & Spear

  1. Great AAR! The game looked excellent – those big blocks of hoplites really make it feel like a proper large battle.

    Thanks for taking the time to walk me through a game. And thanks for not disclosing any of my more serious mistakes (like leaving my general totally unprotected …). 😉

    Like

    1. No problem mate! Thank you for joining me in trying these rules out.

      And as far as your mistakes are concerned, you’re free to blame it all on my imperfect knowledge of the rules – hopefully we won’t have to do any major retcons next time… 😉

      Generals are indeed rather vulnerable (and important) in this game, at least compared to something like Hail Caesar.

      Like

Leave a Reply - no registration needed

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s